Comment to the Article “Prevention of Β Thalassemia in Northern Israel - A Cost-Benefit Analysis” by Koren et al.
Studi Microcitemie, Roma
Received: March 4, 2014
Accepted: March 5, 2014
Meditter J Hematol Infect Dis 2014, 6(1): e2014021, DOI 10.4084/MJHID.2014.021
This article is available on PDF format at:
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
and hemoglobinopathies must be considered the most common genetic blood
disease in the world: in fact, according to the World Health
Organization (WHO), 7% of the global population is a carrier for a
hemoglobin disorders. For this
diseases represent a global public health problem; that is worldwide
common; in addition, current widespread migrations have exacerbated the
situation, by diffusing these diseases from their native areas to other
countries in which they are becoming endemic. The issue of migration
flows has “reshuffled the cards”, not only in those countries in which
hemoglobinopathies and thalassemias were, until now, nearly unknown,
but also in countries whose structures were already well organized to
support the usual load of patients.
dimension of migration events is about to clog the various National
Health Services, not only for mere economic reasons. As a result of
this changed situation, have emerged several needs related to the care
of the patients, including overload transfusion requirements, bone
marrow transplantation requests, the onset of collateral diseases
(hypothyroidism, diabetes mellitus, osteoporosis…) and others; all
these issues are in the limelight today because of the increasing
number of immigrant patients. Due to the rising number of affected
individuals, several International Organizations, that deal with public
health, have given indication to their relative National Health Systems
to take control of the organization of prevention programs, that are
aimed at both precocious detection of carriers and treatment of
Although today we are looking for novel solutions using established procedures (as allogenic bone marrow transplantation) or testing alternative therapeutic approaches (as pharmacological induction of fetal hemoglobin synthesis or gene therapy strategies), such are the issues that prevention still remains the solution for the main part of the problems.
In the mid 70s, prenatal diagnosis was introduced in Italy as a new form of prevention. In exchange for the abortion of the affected fetuses, the possibility to have healthy children to thalassemia carriers couples has been offered todays.
The obtained results and the increasingly wide consent might have given the impression that the problem of the thalassemia prevention was solved: it appeared to be sufficient to examine young couples and to recur to prenatal diagnosis in those cases in which both members were carriers of thalassemia. But, over the years, after this initial approach, more comprehensive prevention strategy, based on the identification of carriers well in advance of the procreation, has been established.
In non-endemic countries, newborn screening and earlier prenatal diagnosis carried out on chorionic villi have been implemented, but this is not enough. In respect of those people who deplore abortion – for ethical reasons or religious choices – preconception prevention programs need to be implemented. These programs are based on both early information and diagnosis of carriers: in fact, the more the information and diagnosis are precocious, the more the choices are thoughtful and aware. Contrary to the case of early information, the interventions that can be undertaken after conception prevent the couples from choosing a number of alternative options. Having had a precocious information, the carriers can choose of not to have a carrier partner, of not to have children, to adopt a child, to use heterologous fertilization (donor gametes), to use pre-implantation diagnosis and not to choose only prenatal diagnosis as the unique alternative to the acceptance of risk.
The prevention program carried out for many years by the Centro Studi Microcitemie of Rome (ANMI Onlus - CSMR) consists in school screening offered to children in the last year of middle school. In addition, being economically very advantageous (about € 6.00/test), this proposal results to be the most ethically acceptable. In this case, the information pertains and involves not only the young people who are directly involved, but also and especially their families, resulting in the final analysis as a valuable tool for education and health care for the entire population. Of course, the prevention program, implemented in Latium in preventing Thalassemia Major, can also be performed in other genetic diseases, such as Tay Sachs disease or Cystic Fibrosis. However, a similar screening program of these hereditary diseases has been developed in Jewish community schools in Australia, and includes mandatory on-site education followed by voluntary on-site genetic carrier testing.
The precise evaluation of health costs presented by Ariel Koren and coauthors in the paper titled “Prevention of β-thalassemia in Northern Israel–A cost-benefit analysis” is very appreciable, but the activity of sanitary prevention, usable by a wide variety of people who are different for culture, religion and ethical values, can not be limited by mere economic evaluation. In particular, the early information given to healthy carriers must be considered: the costs of prevention programs offered at school age are fully justified if to these young thalassemia carriers is given the opportunity of freely and timely choosing among different preventive options, not limiting them to the only choice of therapeutic abortion, that remains a painful, emotionally heavy and drastic solution.
- Koren A, Profeta L,
Zalman L, Palmor H,
Levin K, Bril Zamir R, Shalev S and Blondheim O. Prevention of ß
Thalassemia in Northern Israel - a Cost-Benefit Analysis. Mediterr J
Hematol Infect Dis 2014, 6(1): e2014012, http://dx.doi.org/10.4084/mjhid.2014.012
- Management of birth defects and haemoglobin disorders. Report of a joint WHO-March of Dimes Meeting. Geneva-Switzerland 17-19 May 2006
- Amato A, Giordano PC. Screening and genetic diagnosis of hemoglobinopathies in Southern and Northern Europe: two examples. Medit J of Hemat Infect Dis 2009, 1: http://dx.doi.org/10.4084/MJHID.2009.007
- Angastiniotis M, Vives Corrons JL, Soteriades ES, Eleftheriou A. The impact of migrations on the health services for rare diseases in Europe: the example of haemoglobin disorders. The Scientific World Journal. Volume 2013, Article ID 727905, 10 pages.
- Cao A, Furbetta M,
Galanello R, Melis MA,
Angius A, Ximenes A, Rosatelli C, Ruggeri C, Addis M, TuveriT, Falchi
AM, Paglietti E, Scalas MT. Prevention of homozygous beta-thalassemia
by carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis in Sardinia. Am J Hum
Genet. Jul 1981; 33(4): 592-605. PMid:7258188
- Kaufmann JO, Krapels IP, Van Brussel BT, Zekveld-Vroon RC,Oosterwijk JC, van Erp F, van Echtelt J, Zwijnenburg PJ, Petrij F, Bakker E, Giordano PC. After the introduction into the national newborn screening program: who is receiving genetic counseling for hemoglobinopathies in the Netherlands? Public Health Genomics. 2014; 17(1): 16-22. http://dx.doi.org/10.1159/000355223 PMid:24216604
- Amato A, Cappabianca MP, Lerone M, Colosimo A, Grisanti P, Ponzini D, Di biagio P, Perri M, Gianni D, Rinaldi S, Piscitelli R. Carrier screening for inherited haemoglobin disorders among secondary school students and young adults in Latium, Italy. J Community Genet. 2013 Oct 27.
- Amato A, Lerone M, Grisanti P, Gizzi L, Kaufmann JO, Giordano PC. Providing appropriate genetic information to healthy carriers of hemoglobinopathy can be a welcome and safe initiative: the Latium example. Genet Test Mol Biomarkers. 2012 Jul; 16 (7): 734-738. http://dx.doi.org/10.1089/gtmb.2011.0290 PMid:22731645
- Barlow-Stewart K, Burnett L, Proos A, Howell V, Huq F, Lazarus R, Aizenberg H. A genetic screening programme for Tay-Sachs disease and cystic fibrosis for Australian Jewish high school students. J Med Genet. 2003 Apr; 40 (4): e45. http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/jmg.40.4.e45 PMCid:PMC1735444