The Start-Up of the first Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation Center in the Iraqi Kurdistan: a Capacity-Building Cooperative Project by the Hiwa Cancer Hospital, Sulaymaniyah, and the Italian Agency for Development Cooperation: an Innovative Approach
Ignazio Majolino1, Dosti Othman2, Attilio Rovelli1, Dastan Hassan2, Luqman Rasool2, Michele Vacca1, Nigar Abdalrahman2, Chra Abdullah2, Zhalla Ahmed2, Dlir Ali2, Kosar Ali2, Chiara Broggi1, Cinzia Calabretta1, Marta Canesi1, Gloria Ciabatti1, Claudia Del Fante1, Elisabetta De Sapio1, Giovanna Dore1, Andrea Frigato1, Marcela Gabriel1, Francesco Ipsevich1, Harem Kareem2, Dana Karim2, Rosa Leone1, Tavan Mahmood2, Annunziata Manna1, Maria Speranza Massei1, Andrea Mastria1, Dereen Mohammed2, Rebar Mohammed2, Khoshnaw Najmaddin2, Diana Noori2, Angelo Ostuni1, Angelo Palmas1, Marco Possenti1, Ali Qadir2, Giorgio Real1, Rebwar Shrif2, Caterina Valdatta1, Stefania Vasta1, Marta Verna1, Mariangela Vittori1, Awder Yousif2, Francesco Zallio1, Alessandro Calisti1 , Sergio Quattrocchi3 and Corrado Girmenia1.
Received: February 16, 2017
Accepted: March 20, 2017
Mediterr J Hematol Infect Dis 2017, 9(1): e2017031 DOI 10.4084/MJHID.2017.031
This article is available on PDF format at:
| This is an Open Access article distributed
under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
describe the entire process leading to the start-up of a hematopoietic
stem cell transplantation center at the Hiwa Cancer Hospital, in the
city of Sulaymaniyah, Kurdistan Iraqi Region. This capacity building
project was funded by the Italian Development Cooperation Agency and
implemented with the support of the volunteer work of Italian
professionals, either physicians, nurses, biologists and technicians.
The intervention started in April 2016, was based exclusively on
training and coaching on site, that represent a significant innovative
approach, and led to a first autologous transplant in June 2016 and to
the first allogeneic transplant in October. At the time of reporting, 9
months from the initiation of the project, 18 patients have been
transplanted, 15 with an autologous and 3 with an allogeneic graft. The
center at the HCH represents the first transplantation center in
Kurdistan and the second in wide Iraq. We conclude that international
development cooperation may play an important role also in the field of
high-technology medicine, and contribute to improved local centers
capabilities through country to country scientific exchanges. The
methodology to realize this project is innovative, since HSCT experts
are brought as volunteers to the center(s) to be started, while
traditionally it is the opposite, i.e. the local professionals to be
trained are brought to the specialized center(s).
The Hiwa Cancer Hospital (HCH) of Sulaymaniyah is a leading oncology institution in Iraqi Kurdistan. In 2015, the Institute for University Cooperation (ICU) of Rome identified this center as a possible target for a project of high-technology medical intervention addressed to the development of a HSCT center devoted to the treatment of malignant and non-malignant hematologic disorders, in particular thalassemia major, which represents a major problem in the country. A transplantation expert from Italy made a preliminary visit to the HCH, confirming the feasibility of a stem cell transplantation program. A capacity-building project was designed and submitted to the Italian Development Cooperation Agency (AICS), which approved its funding on March 2016.
Capacity building is the process by which individuals, organizations, institutions and societies develop abilities to perform functions, solve problems and set and achieve objectives. In this paper we describe the entire process leading to the start-up of the Center, the results obtained 9 months after the start of the project and future perspectives. This is the first stem cell transplantation center established in the Kurdistan Region, and the second in Iraq. We conclude that international development cooperation may be of great value in the field of high-technology medicine and contribute to improved local centers’ capabilities, through country-to-country scientific exchanges. Moreover, on-site training and coaching proves an effective innovative method to establish a sustainable activity in developing countries, as alternative to a more traditional methodology, where local professionals to be trained are brought to the specialized center(s) with higher expenditure and less predictable final results.
During the first visit, an appropriate grid, already successfully employed in other circumstances and containing all the necessary questions, was applied to verify the adequacy of the hospital itself and of all the necessary services that are normally involved in HSCT. The areas involved in the process were those listed in table 1. The director of HCH and most of the single-sector responsible physicians or administrators were interviewed. Inspections were also conducted to better ascertain the availability and functioning of instrumentations and devices. At the end of the visit, a positive evaluation was released, confirming the feasibility of a capacity building project for the start-up of a stem cell transplantation activity. A simplified scheme of our project is shown in figure 1.
|Table 1. Areas of the Hiwa Hospital that were explored in the preliminary assessmen. Hinari is a programme set up by WHO together with major publishers, that enables low- and middle- income countries to gain access to one of the world's largest collections of biomedical and health literature (http://www.who.int/hinari/en/).|
|Figure 1. Schematic representation of the capacity building project at the Hiwa Cancer Hospital. Agenzia Italiana per la Cooperazione allo Siluppo Italian Agency for Development Cooperation (AICS).|
Project definition and funding: The second step was designing the project. This was done according to a call for proposal (n. 10548/02/0) by the Italian Ministry for Foreign Affairs – General Direction for Development Cooperation. A capacity building project was submitted by ICU, approved and funded in December 2015. The assigned budget was € 329,000. The contribution of HCH itself to the financial plan consisted of existing instrumentation and laboratory facilities, but the HCH also provided for the accommodation of the volunteers for the whole duration of the project.
Unfortunately, still in the month of December 2015 a fire accident suddenly developed in the TU, due to malfunctioning of the air-treatment unit, with severe damage to the whole TU for a cost of approx. $ 200,000. Though this obviously represented a factor for a possible delay or even suspension of the project, the scientific advisor of ICU and the responsible for AICS prompted for a rapid restoration of the TU, that HCH started in April 2016. The delay was therefore minimal, and the team could begin the training activity the same month, while the restoration works were ended in July.
The capacity building process: To reach the target of a self-sustainable HSCT activity at the HCH, efforts were directed to the training of local personnel, in particular to perform functions, solve problems and set and achieve objectives. The scientific advisor of the project also coordinated the volunteers who delivered training with lectures and seminars, and were also in charge of editing and verifying protocols, as well as of steering clinical work and coaching the local personnel. This was done by attending the morning patient tour and the afternoon outpatient clinic, or participating to the laboratory activities. The personnel involved in the HSCT program, either Italian and Kurdish, also attended the regular weekly activities, such as the morning briefings (every working-day), the weekly seminars on clinical and scientific issues, the transplantation meetings (once a week) with discussion of all the transplantation cases. The chairman of the transplantation meeting regularly took minutes that were regularly distributed to all participants.
The apheresis facility was the first to be started with 2 new-generation cell separators, a Fresenius Comtec, and an Amicus Fenwall device. A reliable and easy to use flow-cytometry double platform technique for CD34+ cell enumeration was assessed, based on a well established methodology. The manipulation laboratory and a technique for cell cryopreservation were set up by the Italian team and implanted in the HCH. A well-equipped transplantation sterile ward, with 6 HEPA-filtered, positive pressure, conditioned-air single rooms was already present and ready for use. At the beginning the cryopreservation was carried out by means of a -80°C mechanical freezer alone, but later a fully equipped liquid nitrogen tank was supplied and cells were initially freezed in the -80°C to be later stored in the liquid phase of liquid nitrogen.
One month later, a series of patients underwent clinical selection procedures based on previously approved criteria and including age, general performance, organ function, disease phase and informed consent, and some of them were finally admitted for the stem cell collection and cryopreservation in view of the autologous transplantation. For stem cell mobilization, in patients with multiple myeloma we used a protocol with G-CSF alone (G-CSF 10 µg/kg/day until the CD34+ cell collection target was achieved, usually day 5), while in lymphoma patients harvest was done in the context of the advanced disease protocol itself. This was BeGeV in Hodgkin lymphoma, DHAP in non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas, always with addition of G-CSF 10 µg/kg/day since the end of chemotherapy to the day when CD34+ cell collection target was achieved. In some cases, also the intermediate-dose (2 to 4 g/m2) cyclophosphamide mobilization protocol[6,7] was employed. Since in this phase of the program only single transplants were planned, a target of 5 x 106/Kg CD34+ cells was set, using an algorithm to have an accurate collection prediction, with an intention to increase the value as soon as the preliminary results would confirm us of the adequacy of the procedures in view of a double autologous transplantation program.
First autologous transplants: A first autologous transplant was carried out 3 months after the program was started in a multiple myeloma patient, using melphalan 140 mg/m2 as high-dose regimen and peripheral blood stem cells (PBSC) as autograft. The engraftment was prompt without major complications. The following month another myeloma patient was successfully autografted, and the program was therefore set out with a series of candidates either with myeloma or malignant lymphoma. Since July, when the HSCT Unit restoration was completed, the transplants were all carried out in the new ward. The clinical characteristics of the patients and the data of stem cell collection, transplantation and engraftment are reported in table 4. There were 15 patients, 11 males and 4 females. Median age was 40 years (range 20 to 60). MM patients were 7, HL were 6 and NHL were 2. Status of disease was CR1 in 4, CR2 in 5, PR1 in 3 and SR in 2. Following the high-dose therapy, all the patients received G-CSF 5 mcg/kg to speed engraftment. All received antiviral and antifungal prophylaxis. The median number of CD34+ cells infused was 5.5 x 106/Kg (range 4.6 to 20.0). All patients fully engrafted but one who died with an acute heart failure on day+19 with granulocyte engraftment but without platelet engraftment. In this series, granulocyte engraftment (≥0.5 x 109/L) occurred on (median) day +11 with a narrow range from 9 to 12. Platelet engraftment (≥20.0 x 109/L) occurred on (median) day +12, range 10 to 17. Thirteen out of the 15 patients underwent a febrile complication, with or without bacterial isolation. Only one patient had a life-threatening complication, with intestinal perforation, but underwent a successful surgical intervention. Data on disease reevaluation are not presented as follow-up is currently too short. All patients but one are alive at a median of 75 days from transplant (range 15-223).
|Table 4. Autologous transplantation: characteristics of the patients, time to engraftment and survival.|
First allogeneic transplants: The initial allogeneic program was set up with the aim to offer a cure to the most frequent hematological disease in the region, i.e. thalassemia. More than one thousand patients with thalassemia live in the area of Sulaymaniyah, most of them are children belonging to large families and having therefore a high probability of a matched family donor. Patients eligible to transplant were considered those with low-risk characteristics (age ≤ 7 years, liver size ≤ 2 cm below costal margin) and a HLA matched sibling donor.[11,12] A downstaging protocol with hydroxyurea and deferoxamine or deferasirox was adopted in cooperation with the Thalassemia & Congenital Blood Diseases Center in Sulaymaniyah directed by LR. Conditioning regimen included iv busulfan and cyclophosphamide. GvHD and rejection prophylaxis included ATG, from day -12 to -10, and cyclosporin, methotrexate and methylprednisolone. The first allogeneic HSCT was performed on October 8th, 2016 and up to now overall 3 patients (2 females, 1 male) underwent HSCT. All of them received GCSF-primed bone marrow from an HLA matched sibling. All donor/recipient couples shared the same blood group and were CMV concordant, i.e. all CMV positive. Engraftment occurred at a median time of 17 days. No major complications were observed in the early aplastic phase after HSCT. One patient developed grade II aGvHD and other potentially life-threatening complications (CMV enterocolitis, low grade microangiopathy, PRES) which resolved with proper treatment. All three patients have been already discharged at home (on day +25, +27 and +96, respectively); they are alive and well, continuing immunosuppression. Two of them are already transfusion independent, the third, though full donor chimera, having just recovered from many complications, not yet.
We decided to dedicate our efforts to the development of HSCT at the HCH of Sulaymaniyah mainly for two reasons. First, HCH is today the main center in the Kurdish territory treating hematologic malignancies and congenital disorders as thalassemia major, the latter occurring at high frequency in Kurdistan. Second, at the time of our first visit the HCH counted already with most of the facilities necessary for an HSCT program, nevertheless an external support would be needed.
Specifically, in the project we developed at the HCH, the capacity-building methodology addressed the implementation of a sustainable HSCT program through the collaboration with experts in the field of adult hematology, pediatric hemato-oncology, transfusion medicine, apheresis, infectious diseases, nursing, cell manipulation, molecular biology and biophysics coming from different Italian institutions. Almost all these experts had a specific and long-lasting experience in the field of HSCT, and were selected not only on the basis of their competence, but also of their previous experience of cooperation with developing countries. All of them were volunteers, while the non-governmental organization ICU provided funds administration and reporting.
It is a common belief that among the main obstacles in the implementation of technically sophisticated procedures, as it is the case for HSCT, the most important are the frequent lack of a priority scale, the absence of teamwork as well as of appropriate methodology for problem-solving, decision-sharing and quality management. A tendency not to establish a transparent and effective responsibility tree is another factor. All these issues are more prominent in developing countries, where also procurement of resources and consequently of instrumentation and reagents is often critical.
Since the beginning our efforts were dedicated to training. Different techniques were used, not only the traditional lectures and seminars, but principally the coaching method. Written protocols and procedures were developed, and the method of shared decisions was adopted to solve the clinical and laboratory problems. This is a key function not only for the start-up but also for quality control and improvement.
On-site training and coaching represent an innovative method to establish a sustainable activity in developing countries, as alternative to a more traditional one, where local professionals to be trained are brought to the specialized center(s) with higher expenditure and less predictable final results. At present, we have no evidence that on-site training has more efficacy compared with the traditional methodology, and what are the situations where it would be more appropriate. With all the current limitations for immigration policies, in the future more projects based on capacity building on-site will probably be developed, and more data will be available.
With the start-up of the autologous transplantation program in June 2016 the HCH progressively developed an autonomous capacity, and consolidated the technical skills not only in the fields of apheresis, cell manipulation and immunohematology, but also in the infection control. In fact, by the end of 2016 among the 15 patients autografted, only one developed a life-threatening infectious complication, but was eventually rescued. Another patient died, due to sudden heart failure following initial engraftment, a complication likely to be in part linked to age and a borderline cardiac function. More severe criteria for admission were consequently setup. Overall, the preliminary results seem encouraging with prompt and stable hematologic recovery in all and few severe complications.
The allogeneic transplantation program for thalassemia at HCH, carries many advantages for the country: it reduces psychosocial and financial burden for families and allows significant saving for the government. The estimated costs of performing locally HSCT are lower than in the countries where patients were previously referred; a systematic analysis of this costs will soon be performed. Moreover, the new skills acquired together with the continuation of cooperation are paramount for further implementing the activity and extending the transplantation accessibility to children with other disorders, as leukemias, bone marrow failures, immune-deficiencies and others.
Here only the initial results of the HSCT activity at the HCH are reported. We are aware that, after start-up, transplantation activity needs resources and organization over the medium and long term to ensure full autonomy of the Center. To that purpose we also introduced the center to the international context registering it as full member in the EBMT, and promoted the search for scientific grants in order to allow medical doctors and other professionals to visit other centers in Europe and the US. In addition, a new project on pediatric hematology was submitted to the AICS and recently funded. This new project, managed by the NGO AVSI, is aimed at improving biological and clinical aspects of childhood leukemia management at the HCH, but also to strengthen the transplantation program, especially in the allogeneic field.
- Gratwohl A, Pasquini MC, Aljurf M, Atsuta Y,
Baldomero H, Foeken L, Gratwohl M, Bouzas LF7, Confer D, Frauendorfer
K, Gluckman E, Greinix H, Horowitz M, Iida M, Lipton J, Madrigal A,
Mohty M, Noel L, Novitzky N, Nunez J, Oudshoorn M, Passweg J, van Rood
J, Szer J, Blume K, Appelbaum FR, Kodera Y, Niederwieser D; Worldwide
Network for Blood and Marrow Transplantation (WBMT). One million
haemopoietic stem-cell transplants: a retrospective observational
study. Lancet Haematol. 2015 Mar;2(3): e91-100. Epub 2015 Feb 27. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2352-3026(15)00028-9
- Garriga M (2013): The Capacity Building Concept. Available from http://www.coastalwiki.org/wiki/The_Capacity_Building_Concept
B, Siena S, Bregni M, Gianni AM, Grillo P, Sommaruga E. A standardized
flow cytometry protocol for mobilized peripheral CD34+ cells estimation
and collection for autotransplantation in cancer patients. Eur J
Histochem 1994; 38: 21-6. PMid:8547706
L, Cabrespine A, Boiret-Dupré N, Merlin E, Paillard C, Berger M, Bay
JO, Tournilhac O, Halle P. Hematologic, immunologic reconstitution, and
outcome of 342 autologous peripheral blood stem cell transplantations
after cryopreservation in a -80°C mechanical freezer and preserved less
than 6 months. Transfusion. 2013 Mar;53(3):570-8. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1537-2995.2012.03768.x
A, Mazza R, Pulsoni A, Re A, Bonfichi M, Zilioli VR, Salvi F, Merli F,
Anastasia A, Luminari S, Annechini G, Gotti M, Peli A, Liberati AM, Di
Renzo N, Castagna L, Giordano L, Carlo-Stella C. Bendamustine in
combination with gemcitabine and vinorelbine is an effective regimen as
induction chemotherapy before autologous stem-cell transplantation for
relapsed or refractory Hodgkin lymphoma: final results of a multicenter
phase II study. J Clin Oncol. 2016 Sep 20;34(27):3293-9. https://doi.org/10.1200/JCO.2016.66.4466
A, Liberti G, Majolino I, Buscemi F, Scimè R, Gentile S, Vasta S,
Pampinella M, Cappuzzo V, Santoro A. Cyclophosphamide 4 g/m2 plus
rhG-CSF for mobilization of circulating progenitor cells in malignant
lymphomas. Int J Artif Organs. 1993 Dec;16 Suppl 5:30-4.
A, Donohue M, Liu L, Medina B, Corringham S, Ihasz A, Carrier E, Castro
JE, Holman PR, Xu R, Law P, Ball ED, Lane TA. Peripheral blood
progenitor cell mobilization with intermediate-dose cyclophosphamide,
sequential granulocyte-macrophage-colony-stimulating factor and
granulocyte-colony-stimulating factor, and scheduled commencement of
leukapheresis in 225 patients undergoing autologous transplantation.
Transfusion. 2007 Nov;47(11):2153-60. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1537-2995.2007.01440.x PMid:17958545
L, Maresca M, Piccirillo N, Pupella S, Gozzer M, Foddai ML, Vacca M,
Adorno G, Coppetelli U, Paladini U. Accurate prediction of autologous
stem cell apheresis yields using a double variable-dependent method
assures systematic efficiency control of continuous flow collection
procedures. Vox Sang. 2006 Aug;91(2):126-34. PubMed PMID: 16907873. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1423-0410.2006.00796.x PMid:16907873
HA, Al-Allawi NA. Epidemiological profile of common haemoglobinopathies
in Arab countries. J Community Genet. 2013, 4:147-67. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12687-012-0127-8 PMid:23224852 PMCid:PMC3666833
G, Galimberti M, Polchi P, Angelucci E, Baronciani D, Giardini C,
Andreani M, Agostinelli F, Albertini F, Clift RA. Marrow
transplantation in patients with thalassemia responsive to iron
chelation therapy. N Engl J Med. 1993; 329: 840-4. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199309163291204 PMid:8355742
E, Matthes-Martin S, Baronciani D, Bernaudin F, Bonanomi S, Cappellini
MD, Dalle JH, Di Bartolomeo P, de Heredia CD, Dickerhoff R, Giardini C,
Gluckman E, Hussein AA, Kamani N, Minkov M, Locatelli F, Rocha V,
Sedlacek P, Smiers F, Thuret I, Yaniv I, Cavazzana M, Peters C; EBMT
Inborn Error and EBMT Paediatric Working Parties. Hematopoietic stem
cell transplantation in thalassemia major and sickle cell disease:
indications and management recommendations from an international expert
panel. Haematologica. 2014, 99:811-20. https://doi.org/10.3324/haematol.2013.099747 PMid:24790059 PMCid:PMC4008115
M, Chandy M, Wang Z, Logan BR, Ghavamzadeh A, Li CK, Irfan SM, Bredeson
CN, Cowan MJ, Gale RP, Hale GA, Horan J, Hongeng S, Eapen M, Walters
MC. HLA-matched sibling bone marrow transplantation for ß-thalassemia
major. Blood. 2011, 117:1745-50. https://doi.org/10.1182/blood-2010-09-306829 PMid:21119108 PMCid:PMC3056598
- Mathews V, Savani BN. Conditioning regimens in allo-SCT for thalassemia major. Bone Marrow Transplant, 2014; 49:607-10. https://doi.org/10.1038/bmt.2013.216 PMid:24442250
E, Peristeri I, Kitra V, Vessalas G, Paisiou A, Theodosaki M, Petrakou
E, Dimopoulou MN, Graphakos S. HLA-matched sibling stem cell
transplantation in children with ß-thalassemia with anti-thymocyte
globulin as part of the preparative regimen: the Greek experience. Bone
Marrow Transplant, 2012;47:1061-6. https://doi.org/10.1038/bmt.2011.219 PMid:22080966
U, Al-Dawsari G, Couban S, Lipton JH. G-CSF-primed bone marrow as a
source of stem cells for allografting: revisiting the concept. Bone
Marrow Transplant, 2015; 50:1150-6 https://doi.org/10.1038/bmt.2015.80 PMid:25915812
C, Viscoli C, Piciocchi A, Cudillo L, Botti S, Errico A, Sarmati L,
Ciceri F, Locatelli F, Giannella M, Bassetti M, Tascini C, Lombardini
L, Majolino I, Farina C, Luzzaro F, Rossolini GM, Rambaldi A.
Management of carbapenem resistant Klebsiella pneumoniae infections in
stem cell transplant recipients: an Italian multidisciplinary consensus
statement. Haematologica. 2015 Sep;100(9):e373-6. doi:
LB, Uderzo C, Masera G. International cooperation for the cure and
prevention of severe hemoglobinopathies. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2013;
35: 419-23. doi: 10.1097/MPH.0b013e31829cd920. Review. https://doi.org/10.1097/MPH.0b013e31829cd920
Metrics powered by PLOS ALM
Copyright (c) 2017 Mediterranean Journal of Hematology and Infectious Diseases
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.